One of my favorite things to do is try a new (to me) restaurant and it’s something I look forward to every vacation. Below are my favorite paces I ate at while in NYC last month. I’m not a local to New York so I cannot say the places below are the absolute best places to eat in the city, but they certainly were my favorite places we ate at while we explored the city over 11 days. If you are in the city and looking for a great place to eat, these should be on your radar.
Ess-A-Bagel
It’s true what they say…bagels in New York really are superior to all other bagels. I liked this place so much, we went twice. There is usually a line but it moves pretty fast, and it’s worth the wait. I got the pumpernickel bagel with banana nut cream cheese and it was to die for.
Pilot
Pilot is a restaurant on a vintage sailboat docked in the East River. This place has a pretty limited menu. We got the Mermaid Cove Oysters that are sourced from Prince Edward Island and the Scallops. Both items were good (the oysters were the star of the show) but you really go here for the views of the city. I don’t recommend this place if you get motion sickness, as the boat sways quite a bit.
Sogono Toscano
Left Photo from OpenTable
Sogono Toscano is an Italian coffee shop/cafe. This is the perfect place for an afternoon pick-me-up. The tea and espresso were good. I suggest skipping the croissants since there are better places in the city for croissants. You absolutely have to get the Stracciatella though. It’s the only place I’ve found in the US that does a really good and authentic version of it.
Katz’s Deli
Left photo from High Def watch
This deli was made famous from that scene in When Harry Met Sally. There was a small line outside but it moved faster than we expected. My husband and I split their pastrami sandwich on deli rye bread (I definitely suggest splitting it). It was hands down the best pastrami sandwich I’ve ever had.
Eleven Madison Park
Eleven Madison Park is the first 3 Star Michelin restaurant I’ve been to. If you are unfamiliar with the Michelin Star rating system, they only go up to 3 stars. This is one of the top rated restaurants in a city known for good food. This is a plant based restaurant and I had to keep reminding myself of that throughout the meal because it was hard to believe at times. I love going to restaurants that challenge my view of food and this place did that. We opted for the main dining room menu tasting which is nine to ten courses. My husband opted for the wine pairing with the meal and found the wines to be good, but thought it was a little lack luster. I personally skipped the wine pairing because I don’t drink much and there is no way I could handle a glass of wine with each course LOL.
Magnolia Bakery
Magnolia Bakery is a New York icon best known for their cupcakes and banana pudding. They were sold out of the traditional banana pudding when we went so we got the Gone Bananas Banana Pudding and I can see where all the hype comes from. I love banana flavored desserts and this was the best banana flavored dessert I’ve ever had.
Blue Box Cafe
The Blue Box Cafe is located in Tiffany’s flagship store. It’s where you can go to actually have breakfast at Tiffany’s. As an Audrey Hepburn fan, this was a highlight of our trip. Sometimes with novelty cafes, the food can be lacking but my husband and I ordered Breakfast at Tiffany’s option and loved it. You can try for a walk-in but it’s best to make a reservation and reservations are very difficult to get. Reservations open one month from the date you want and they open at midnight eastern time. I got online a couple minutes before reservations opened and refreshed the page until it opened reservations.
John’s of Bleecker St
Photo from Grub Street
My favorite kind of pizza is a thin crust, New York style pizza and this place embodied that. This pizza was so good it actually brought tears to my eyes. Luckily I did not actually cry because that would have been embarrassing.
JG Melon
Photos from jgmelon-nyc.com
One of the nights we were there I really wanted a good cheeseburger. We came across this place on Yelp and I’m so happy we went. The cheeseburgers were good but the real stars of the show were the chili bowl and apple sour cream walnut pie. The chili tasted exactly like my mom’s homemade chili so it was a real comfort food for me. The apple sour cream walnut pie was so good I had a dream about it.